Choosing a web designer feels like a gamble because you can’t see inside the work. You can still stack the odds. Here is how I’d go about it.
Start with their own website
Open it on your phone. Does it load fast? Can you tell what they do in five seconds? Is the phone number easy to find? A designer who can’t make their own site work well is unlikely to do better for yours. And if they say they build sites that rank, see whether their own site shows up when you search for what they do.
Look at live examples, not screenshots
A picture of a website proves very little. Ask for the web addresses of sites they built, and open them yourself. Check them on a phone. See how they load and how easy it is to call. Then search for the business and see what comes up. A real site with real results is worth more than a polished presentation.
Call two of their clients
This is the best hour you will spend. Ask what it was like working with them, whether the project came in on time, how they handled changes, and what happened after launch. Ask one more thing: would you hire them again? If a designer won’t connect you with anyone, take note.
Try to talk to a past client as well as a current one. Past clients tell you how things went when they got difficult.
Ask who does the writing
Some designers build the site and leave the words to you. Some write everything. Neither is wrong, but you need to know, because the words are where the calls come from. Ask who writes the pages, whether they will talk with you about your business first, and whether the writing will sound like you.
Ask about speed, structure and local pages
A good designer can answer in plain words how they make a site fast on a phone, how they structure pages so Google and AI tools can read them, and how they handle pages for different towns. If the answers are vague, so is the plan. A designer who understands Tampa Bay’s patchwork of communities, and who will build pages for the ones you serve, has a real advantage.
Get three written quotes
Compare them line by line, not just by the bottom number. What drives a website’s price explains the items to check. If one quote is far lower or higher than the rest, find out why before you decide.
Confirm what you will own
Before you pay, get it in writing. You should own the website, the pages, the text and images they create for you, the domain and any accounts in your name. Do you own your website walks through how to check, and the contract checklist lists what to ask for.
Signs to slow down
- Pressure to decide today.
- No live examples, or examples that don’t load well.
- Quotes that describe the work in vague terms.
- Reluctance to explain who owns what.
- Promises of guaranteed rankings.
- A price that is very low with a long list of monthly fees.
None of these proves anything by itself. Together they tell you to ask more questions.
Listen to your gut, then check it
You will probably get a feel for whether someone is straight with you. Trust that, and then check it with the steps above. A designer who respects your time and answers the hard questions without getting defensive is usually the right one.
Where we fit
If you would like to talk with us about a build, our web design page explains how we work. We build sites around calls, and we are happy to answer every question on this list. Call us and ask.





